理則學 練習18 範例 (取自梅子姐)
2008/03/02 21:27
瀏覽516
迴響0
推薦3
引用0
B-1 There are ghosts.
轉化成述詞邏輯語句依序經過四次改寫:
第一步改寫:There is something such that it is a ghost.
第二步改寫:There is something y such that y is a ghost.
第三步改寫:(∃y)(y is a ghost)
第四步改寫:(∃y)(Gy)
C-1 (x)(x is in motion ∨x is at rest)
要回答第一個問題之前,要先回答第二個問題,亦即是題目中的變元究竟是自由的還是拘限的,而這樣看變元是否指涉到量詞而定,若變元有指涉到量詞,則為拘限變元,否則就是自由變元。因此此題的x是拘限變元,而自由變元無法用來符號化語句也不能用來檢測量化邏輯的論證,只有拘限變元可以,因此這題可表達出有真假可言的語句。
D-1 (∃x)(x is ancient ∨ x is modern)
第一步改寫:There is something x is such that x is ancient or x is modern
第二步改寫:There is something is such that it is ancient or it is modern
第三步改寫:Something is ancient or modern
第四步英翻中:有些東西是古代的或現代的。




