The song is part of the Great American Songbook and has had many notable recordings, including:

• (1952) Chet Baker had a hit with Gerry Mulligan.
• (1955) Frank Sinatra included it on his album Songs for Young Lovers, and it became a performance favorite.
• (1956) Ella Fitzgerald sang it on her album Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Rodgers & Hart Songbook.
• (1956) Jimmy Giuffre included it on his album The Jimmy Giuffre Clarinet.
• (1956) Miles Davis recorded this tune several times, first on Cookin' in 1956 and again on the album 1958 Miles, the latter demonstrating the modal approach of Davis and pianist Bill Evans. He recorded it live on his 1964 album My Funny Valentine.
• (1958) Dolores Duran sang it on her album A Noite de Dolores.
• (1966) Kazuko Matsuo from Sigh of Night.
• (1967) The Supremes recorded a version for their album The Supremes Sing Rodgers & Hart.
• (1973) Jerry Garcia together with keyboard player Merl Saunders released it on the album Live at the Keystone, providing a psychedelic reading of the tune.
• (1985) Singer songwriter Nico recorded it on the album Camera Obscura, a singular jazz standard on an album of progressive jazz, rock and electronica.
• (1986) Linda Ronstadt played it on her album For Sentimental Reasons.
• (1987) Guitarist Larry Coryell performed a cover from the album Toku Do.^[5]
• (1989) The song is played over the closing credits of the movie The Fabulous Baker Boys, sung by Michelle Pfeiffer.
• (1995) Rachelle Ferrell performed this song in her album First Instrument.
• (1995) This song was included in the motion picture soundtrack "Waiting to Exhale", and was performed by Chaka Khan.
• (1996) Dianne Reeves performed this song in her album '"The Palo Alto Sessions 1981-1985.
• (1999) The French singer-songwriter Damien Saez performed this song in his album Jours Etranges.
• (1999) Matt Damon sang this song on the motion picture soundtrack "The Talented Mr. Ripley", accompanied by The Guy Barker International Quintet.
• (2001) Tony Award winner Kristin Chenoweth recorded this song for her album Let Yourself Go.
• (2002) Guitarist Chuck Loeb covered the song from his album My Shining Hour.^[6]
• (2002) Contemporary jazz-fusion group Pieces of a Dream covered the song from their album Love's Silhouette.^[7]
• (2003) Trumpeter Chris Botti covered the song from album A Thousand Kisses Deep.^[8][9]
• (2008) Sal Viviano included it on his live symphonic album The Standards Of Love.
• (2009) Joshua Bell and singer Kristin Chenoweth covered the song on the album At Home with Friends.
• (2009) Fay Claassen in Odeon Theatre Amsterdam. On album 'Two Portraits of Chet Baker'
• (2011) Jenna Ushkowitz sings this song in Fox series Glee.
• (2011) Vanessa Williams sings in TV series Desperate Housewives.